FAQBuilding settlement and cracking
WSA Phase 2 · settlement monitoring · as at MN55 (3 Nov 2026)

Coordination meeting, 10 November 2026Frequently asked questions

FAQQuestionSlide
FAQ 1Latest finding: where has the building settled, and where is it heading? (MN55 contour, settlement and lean)2-4
FAQ 3After completion, will settlement keep increasing? Can we predict it now?5
FAQ 4On record: requests to the Substructure Engineer6
FAQ 5What has happened, and when? (chronology)7
FAQ 6Who must give the allowable settlement values?8
FAQ 7Is the building safe? (rev 1, MN55)9-11
FAQ 2Is the lean of the building easing? (steeper or leaner)12
Numbers as at MN55 (3 November 2026) unless stated. Arrow keys or a tap on the right or left of the slide move between slides; tap a row above to jump to it.
FAQ 1Latest finding: settlement contour at MN55
WSA Phase 2 · settlement monitoring · as at MN55 (3 Nov 2026)

Latest reading, MN55, 3 November 2026Where has the building settled?

What the picture shows

Dark is settled most, light is settled least. Settlement is measured from the start (MN0).
  • Most: BSM10 84.23 mm, BSM1 79.75 mm, BSM9 78.68 mm (east side)
  • Least: BSM7 16.16 mm, BSM5 20.83 mm (west side)
  • The east settles more than the west, so the raft leans towards BSM10 and BSM1.
  • Tilt of the whole building 1/1409; the pair closest to 1/1000 is 1/1204. Both are within 1/1000.
Settlement is still increasing
Source: HIZ letter HIZC/24.05/WKE/18 (9 Nov 2026), p.2, Figure 1; Nattest Lab NTP26/0374 (MN55). Triangles P1 to P4 are extrapolated, not measured.
FAQ 1Latest finding: settlement against floor level
WSA Phase 2 · settlement monitoring · as at MN55 (3 Nov 2026)

Latest reading against the trend fitted to MN29 to MN54Settlement is still increasing

BSM10 reached 84.23 mm at MN55, above its trend line. BSM1 (79.75 mm) and BSM9 (78.68 mm) are also above their trend lines.
Source: HIZ letter HIZC/24.05/WKE/18 (9 Nov 2026), p.3, Figure 2, settlement panel for BSM10 (BSM1 and BSM9 panels on the same figure). Trend fitted to MN29 to MN54, MN55 added and not refitted. Roof is assumed.
FAQ 1Latest finding: tilt of the whole building
WSA Phase 2 · settlement monitoring · as at MN55 (3 Nov 2026)

Tilt of the best-fit plane through the settlement markersWhere is the lean heading?

How to read it

  • MN55 tilt is 1/1409 (MN54 about 1/1450), within 1/1000.
  • At the roof the trend is about 1/1210; the range goes to about 1/1140.
  • 1/1000 is the Eurocode value for buildings 100 m or taller.
Tilt is the lean of the whole building
Source: HIZ letter HIZC/24.05/WKE/18 (9 Nov 2026), p.3, Figure 2, tilt panel; 1/1000 from BS EN 1990:2023 Tables A.1.15 and A.1.16 (cited, as in the figure). Trend fitted to MN29 to MN54, MN55 added and not refitted.
FAQ 3After completion
WSA Phase 2 · settlement monitoring · as at MN55 (3 Nov 2026)

Your question, 10 NovAfter the building is complete, will settlement keep increasing? Can we predict it now?

Not known yet which path. The lean is still growing, no sign of easing. After completion no more weight is added: the rate reduces, but the lean still increases at a lower rate. Final value not certain, to be monitored.
FAQ 4On record: requests to the Substructure Engineer
WSA Phase 2 · settlement monitoring · as at MN55 (3 Nov 2026)

Why HIZ keeps writingThe foundation question has been with the Substructure Engineer, in writing, since October 2025

DateLetter or reportWhat HIZ asked
17 Oct 2025 (e-mailed 18 Oct)HIZC/24.05/WKE/7 + SM/03After a rise of about 9 mm at BSM10 (MN11 to MN12): readings to be reviewed by the substructure package engineer; WKE to notify UDA Land (North) for the Package 1 foundation review (para 2(d), 2(e))
Oct 2025 to May 2026Reports SM/03 to SM/06Review of the settlement requested again
12 May 2026HIZC/24.05/WKE/9Precautionary notice; asks WKE to consult the Substructure Engineer
18 May 2026HIZC/24.05/WKE/10Asks again for the Substructure Engineer's values
3 Jul 2026HIZC/24.05/WKE/14Interim levels set; Substructure Engineer's values and comments asked
12 Oct 2026HIZC/24.05/WKE/16 + SM/10Asks again for the Substructure Engineer's values
30 Oct 2026HIZC/24.05/WKE/17 + SM/11Formal review called for; formal written reply asked on items a to f
9 Nov 2026HIZC/24.05/WKE/18Latest findings; request restated in full, copied to the Substructure Engineer
To dateSubstructure EngineerNo written reply with the allowable values received (10 Nov 2026)
Within the superstructure package, HIZ (consultant) and WKE (contractor) have played their part: monitored every cycle, reported each round, and asked in writing. What remains is the Substructure Engineer's input on the foundation (WKE/17 para 10).
The Substructure Engineer has to respond. Limiting values for foundation movements are set in foundation design (BS EN 1997-1 cl. 2.4.9(1)P), and HIZ has no authority to set them. A formal letter from the Substructure Engineer itself is asked (WKE/17, WKE/18 para 7).
Sources: HIZC/24.05/WKE/7 (17 Oct 2025, e-mailed to WKE 18 Oct 2025 14:33) para 2(d), 2(e); HIZC/24.05/WKE/17 Appendix 1 chronology and paras 8, 10, 14 (WKE/18 pack pp.5-10); HIZC/24.05/WKE/18 (e-mailed 9 Nov 2026 09:44 to WKE, copied to UDA Land (North), DNP, the Substructure Engineer, Mewah Kota). Standards cited by clause only.
FAQ 5Chronology
WSA Phase 2 · settlement monitoring · as at MN55 (3 Nov 2026)

What has happened, and when?

DateEventReference
A. Monitoring and requests to the Substructure Engineer
16 Oct 2024Settlement monitoring starts (MN0)Nattest Lab
17 Oct 2025After a rise of about 9 mm (MN11 to MN12), HIZ asks, through WKE, for the readings to be reviewed by the substructure package engineer (e-mailed 18 Oct)WKE/7, SM/03
12 May 2026HIZ precautionary notice; independent Licensed Land Surveyor asked to counter-checkWKE/9
13 May 2026UDA Land (North): angular distortion, not total settlement alone, governs assessmentUDA (81)
18 May 2026HIZ asks again for the Substructure Engineer's valuesWKE/10
9 Jun 2026MN27: Nattest Lab and Syarikat Ayob records consistentSM/07
B. Resumption under monitoring
23 Jun 2026Works may proceed under continued monitoring, pre-set levels for formal reviewWKE/13, SM/07
25 Jun 2026Meeting at UDA HQ: HIZ and NMI & Associates (Independent Checker) present findingsUDA (90)
30 Jun 2026UDA Land (North) instructs resumption of worksUDA (90)
3 Jul 2026HIZ interim levels for formal review; Substructure Engineer's values askedWKE/14
22-23 Sep 2026Independent Checker report receivedUDA (108)
12 Oct 2026Report SM/10 submitted; values asked againWKE/16
16 Oct 2026Ir. Nazri (NMI): allowable values to be set by the foundation engineerDiscussion
C. Latest
30 Oct 2026Report SM/11 (to MN54): formal review called for; 1/1000 applied to pairs 30 m or more and to tiltWKE/17
3 Nov 2026MN55: BSM10 84.23 mm; Syarikat Ayob surveys the same dayNTP26/0374, NO-SM-39
9 Nov 2026Latest findings (MN55); request to the Substructure Engineer restated in fullWKE/18
Source: HIZC/24.05/WKE/17 Appendix 1 (WKE/18 pack pp.9-10), extended with WKE/18. Letters are HIZC/24.05/WKE/n; UDA letters ref. dlm P3751/0107/0200 (40). No written reply from the Substructure Engineer to date.
HIZ has asked, in writing, for the allowable settlement and angular distortion to be given, and set interim levels while waiting. The letters are listed in FAQ 4.
FAQ 7Is the building safe? REV 1, 10 Nov 2026
WSA Phase 2 · settlement monitoring · as at MN55 (3 Nov 2026)

Frequently asked questionIs the building safe?

The monitoring shows no sign of structural distress. The tilt and every pair of markers 30 m or more apart are within 1/1000, and no structural cracking has been recorded. Settlement continues (84.23 mm at BSM10). The allowable values are for the Substructure Engineer to give; HIZ has asked since October 2025.

1. The foundation is a Package 1 matter

The foundation was designed and built first, under Package 1. Under the Supplemental Agreement (Clause 6), the Government warrants the foundation for the DNP Design 2 load. HIZ is the Superstructure Engineer, Ground Floor up (VE2 = HIZ).

2. No structural cracking

Cracks reported in the brickwork were assessed as non-structural (memo HIZ/WSA_P2/MEMO/03). Distress or structural cracking at any time calls for a formal review.

3. Lean and bending within 1/1000

Tilt 1/1409. Worst pair 30 m or more: BSM1 and BSM4, 1/1204. Both within the 1/1000 HIZ applies (WKE/17 para 8).

4. Settlement still increasing

About 4 mm per floor cast, not easing (FAQ 3). At BSM10, BSM1 and BSM9 it sits above the projected range (WKE/18 para 4).
Sources: HIZC/24.05/WKE/18 paras 2-4 (p.1); HIZC/24.05/WKE/17 paras 8, 10 (WKE/18 pack pp.6-7); Supplemental Agreement 16 July 2025, Clause 6 (printed p.6); Nattest Lab NTP26/0374. Rev 1 replaces rev 0 of 16 Oct 2026 (MN50, 1/500 and 1/750 basis).
FAQ 7Is the building safe? REV 1, 10 Nov 2026
WSA Phase 2 · settlement monitoring · as at MN55 (3 Nov 2026)

Is the building safe?Where the readings stand at MN55

QuantityMN55Value HIZ applies, or referenceRoof (slab 41), trend
Tilt of the building1/14091/1000 (BS EN 1990:2023 Tables A.1.15, A.1.16, buildings 100 m or taller)about 1/1210 (range to 1/1140)
Angular distortion, worst pair 30 m or more (BSM1 and BSM4)1/12041/1000 (WKE/17); for reference 1/667 framed buildings (Table A.1.14), 1/500 (BS EN 1997-1 Annex H)about 1/1060 (upper edge 1/990)
Largest settlement difference (BSM4 to BSM10, about 72 m apart)52.45 mmNo value given. Reference: 100 mm for utility connections only (BS EN 1990:2023 Table A.1.13); not monitored
Total settlement, highest (BSM10)84.23 mmNo allowable value given by the Substructure Engineer. Reference: up to 50 mm often acceptable for normal structures on isolated foundations (Annex H(4))still increasing
In plain words: the building leans and bends less than the 1/1000 HIZ applies. Settlement itself has no allowable value yet; that is for the Substructure Engineer, who has been asked in writing since October 2025 (FAQ 4).
What changes this answer: the tilt or any pair 30 m or more reaching 1/1000, or distress or structural cracking: a formal review is called for.
Sources: WKE/18 paras 3-4 and Figure 2; WKE/17 paras 5, 8, 13. Largest difference: HIZ arithmetic from series.csv (MN55 BSM10 84.23 minus BSM4 31.78 mm; method gives 47.5 mm at MN50, as in rev 0). HIZ's levels are interim monitoring levels, not allowable values. Standards cited by clause only.
FAQ 7Is the building safe? REV 1, 10 Nov 2026
WSA Phase 2 · settlement monitoring · as at MN55 (3 Nov 2026)

Is the building safe?Our position

  1. The foundation is Package 1's, under the Supplemental Agreement: the Government warrants it for the DNP Design 2 load (Clause 6).
  2. Construction continues under continued monitoring, unless the Substructure Engineer advises otherwise (WKE/17 para 10).
  3. We monitor settlement, the three pairs, the tilt and cracks every round, with Syarikat Ayob as the independent check.
  4. If the tilt or any pair 30 m or more reaches 1/1000, or distress or structural cracking is seen, a formal review is called for.
  5. The allowable values are set in foundation design, by the Substructure Engineer (BS EN 1997-1 cl. 2.4.9(1)P). HIZ has no authority to set them.
Asked in writing since 17 Oct 2025 (WKE/7), latest 9 Nov 2026 (WKE/18). No written reply from the Substructure Engineer to date. Full list: FAQ 4.
In plain words: the foundation is Package 1's. We look after our package and keep watch on the building as it goes up, and after it is complete (FAQ 3).
Sources: Supplemental Agreement Clause 6 (printed p.6); HIZC/24.05/WKE/7 para 2(d), 2(e); WKE/17 paras 8, 10, 14; WKE/18 paras 2, 7.
FAQ 2Is the lean easing?
WSA Phase 2 · settlement monitoring · as at MN55 (3 Nov 2026)

And the lean and bending: steeper or leaner?

Still increasing. Per floor cast, compared with before: the whole building's lean (tilt) and the bending between BSM1 and BSM4 grow slower; between BSM6 and BSM9 the same; between BSM2 and BSM10 slightly faster.
Not a sign that settlement is ending. One reading moves about as much as one floor of growth. Whether it is easing is for the Substructure Engineer.
Sketches not to scale. Growth per floor, Level 33.6-37.6 vs 31-33.6: tilt 0.76, BSM1 and BSM4 0.64, BSM6 and BSM9 1.02, BSM2 and BSM10 1.14 (HIZ trend working, 7 Nov). WKE/18 para 6 compared with the five levels before, which include the May-July casting hold (about half). Plan: marker positions from the project coordinates; grey = BSM5, BSM7 (not used). Shading = best-fit plane through the eight markers at MN55 (tilt 1/1409), darker where it has settled more; the arrow spans the raft to show the whole building leans; its length is not the size of the lean.
Turn your phone sideways for a larger slide